Serving Southeast Michigan For Over 30 Years.

Practice Makes Perfect

Preparing Your Appearance

By Donald P. DeNault, Jr.

When preparing your appearance or any other case caption involving a civil infraction, the proper "plaintiff" is the municipality, not "the people" of that municipality. In other words, the proper caption is "City of Sterling Heights v Tella Graham." Don't use "People of the City of Sterling Heights" because the matter is a civil case, not a criminal prosecution. The "People" of a municipal entity don't usually sue anyone. They prosecute when the violation is criminal, but they don't sue for civil concerns.

Of course, there's always an exception to every rule, and sometimes the exception doesn't make any sense. If the civil infraction is a violation of the Michigan Vehicle Code (not a local ordinance that adopts the Vehicle Code, nor an ordinance that calls itself a vehicle code, but rather the actual, honest-to-goodness Vehicle Code), then the proper caption is "People v Jay Walker."

According to MCL 257.741, though, the proper "plaintiff" for civil infraction violations of the Vehicle Code is actually the State. Nevertheless, the rule adopted by the Michigan Supreme Court is to use "People" rather than "State." This rule completely contradicts the notion that the People don't sue, but apparently no one ever really thought it through that far.

What to do if your next client is charged with criminal and civil infraction violations? Well, most of us have become accustomed to just using one simple caption, like "People v Noah Lott." However, the proper approach is probably to prepare two separate captions and treat the cases as separate and distinct. After all, one gets a trial and the other gets a formal hearing, right? But that's a topic for a future teachable moment...

Source: The Michigan Uniform System of Citation, Section (I)(A)(4)(g).

View PDF of article

For More Information

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Press Room

Jan
20
Mark Breaugh joined the O’Reilly Rancilio legal team as an associate on Jan. 18, 2021. Mr. Breaugh is part of the firm’s litigation and disputes practice group.… Read More
Dec
28
2020 was undoubtedly a memorable year that was full of unprecedented challenges for everyone. As the world perseveres through the COVID-19 pandemic, the legal team a… Read More
Read More From Our Press Room

Blog

Jan
20
A law, signed into effect in October of 2020, amends the Commercial Rehabilitation Act and the Commercial Redevelopment Act so that the granting of property tax abat… Read More
Jan
14
You may be years away from the transferring of your business to the next generation. Advanced planning provides you with more options and flexibility, resulting in a… Read More
Read More From Our Blog